Myten om de ändliga resurserna

Showing page 2 of 3: 1  2  3
Inlägg #21: Postat: 2002-11-17 20:33:00
Frederik
It again demonstrates my point: according to theory it all should work fine. In practice however it rarely ever does.
Inlägg #22: Postat: 2002-11-17 21:28:00
Stefan
Ex. Stiglitz har berättat mycket ingående om hur "åtgärder" har havererat hela regioner och handelssystem runtom i världen, allt i avregleringens heliga välsignade tecken. Och i övrigt är vedeldning nödvändigt för otroligt många människor runtom i världen. Av den enda och enkla anledningen att ved är gratis. Hur tror du folk som saknar pengar skulle reagera på om någon plötsligt krävde betalt för eldved? Upplopp!
Inlägg #23: Postat: 2002-11-17 21:30:00
Stefan
Fast å andra sidan är det ju just upplopp vi ser runtom i världen när marknader för livsnödvändiga resurser avregleras. Sydamerika har många bra exempel. Varit där?
Inlägg #24: Postat: 2002-11-17 23:58:00
Frederik
...one more argument though again not about natural resources: people in developing countries would be happy if the health risks of using firewood were their biggest problem. Unfortunately its again market mechanisms that prevents the real health problems to be tackled.
Inlägg #25: Postat: 2002-11-17 23:59:00
Frederik
For pharmaceutical companies it simply pays more to keep rich mens dicks stiff through Viagra than to do research on vaccines for tuberculosis or malaria, which literally kill millions of poor people every year.
Inlägg #26: Postat: 2002-11-18 02:33:00
David Woxberg
Frederik: Right, blaim "the market" for the poverty in non-capitalist economies. If so, you ignore the fact that virtually no country has ever grown rich and deleted its poverty and hunger without liberalisation.
Inlägg #27: Postat: 2002-11-18 02:36:00
David Woxberg
It is of extreme significance that the poor countries of the world rid themselves from such things as inflation, corruption, regulations, tariffs, monopolies and subsidies of various sorts in order to get the trade going and create wealth. It is also important to establish a sound legal system, in which individual rights, including property-rights, are respected.
Inlägg #28: Postat: 2002-11-18 02:40:00
David Woxberg
Welfare states generally do not develop until after a country has opened its markets and created some portion of wealth which can be distributed in the creation of educational systems and other things. In order to distribute, one must create the means for doing it.
Inlägg #29: Postat: 2002-11-18 02:48:00
David Woxberg
And: Without the medical industry, there would be no medicines. You do not seem to take into consideration the considerable time, research and capital which it takes to create a medicine. An argument like that implies that the medical companies should devote all this time without being payed, only to give their medicines away for free. Talk about spitting the producers in the face...
Inlägg #30: Postat: 2002-11-18 02:56:00
David Woxberg
The medical companies has "created" medical inequalities only in the sense that Gutenbergs printing press created illiteracy in the Fifteenth Century. Remember that no-one would promote such a leftist-argument if ALL people were suffering from Tuberculosis or Malaria. The medial companies has created the possibility for a lot of people to cure their diseases. The fact that other people are still suffering does IN NO WAY erase this noble achievement.
Inlägg #31: Postat: 2002-11-18 03:03:00
David Woxberg
Okej Stefan, då struntar vi i att liberalisera och fortsätter se miljontals människor dö av den vedbaserade inomhuseldningen. Det viktiga är inte att veden ska börja kosta pengar, utan att man kan komma igång med en ordentlig arbetsdelning så att välståndet kan börja växa och andra resurser kan börja användas vid matlagningen som en positiv konsekvens.
Inlägg #32: Postat: 2002-11-18 11:29:00
Stefan
Du snackar långt över huvudet på alla miljoner vanliga människor runtom i världen som lever på existensminimum och tar vad som finns i den omedelbara närheten bara för att få livet att gå runt på dags- eller veckobasis. Om folk inte vill ha privatiserade och konkurrensutsatta grundresurser som ex dricksvatten, ska dom inte få det då, eller måste "landet" agera över deras huvuden eftersom dom inte förstår landets ekonomins bästa? Det är inte bara ekonomer som tänker här i världen!
Inlägg #33: Postat: 2002-11-18 11:36:00
Frederik
David: Im not saying that pharmaceutical companies should do their work for free. Non ones so stupid to claim that. And dont be so quick in attributing ideological labels to arguments, please. If truth is really what Im after, then I should be wary of any ideological talk, including my own.
Inlägg #34: Postat: 2002-11-18 11:36:00
Frederik
Anyway, my point is that some fields of research should be subsidised even though they dont pay off on the short term. Compare it to fundamental nuclear research: some of the topics my father researched were questionable from a practical point of view, and seemed more like multi-million-dollar projects that exist solely for the purpose of the entertainment of the physicists that run them.
Inlägg #35: Postat: 2002-11-18 11:39:00
Frederik
The point is however that on the *long run* this research *may* produce fundamental knowledge that *may* have significant practical implications. Market-thinking however tends to focus on short-term solutions shareholders will always choose to invest where the benefit is both quickest and highest, right?. And care for the poor obviously has no tangible financial short-term benefit whatsoever.
Inlägg #36: Postat: 2002-11-18 11:46:00
Frederik
...as for answer 27: should rid themselves is too easy a claim. If youve really studied a bit the realities of developing countries youll again realise that things arent that simple and straightforward. Its full of chicken-and-egg problems, with A being caused by B being caused by C being caused by A again.
Inlägg #37: Postat: 2002-11-18 11:50:00
Frederik
...concerning 28: Im not ideologically opposed to market liberalisation, and Im convinced that in some areas it does have significant benefits. I however dont think that its a panacea, and lots of areas exist where it fails blatantly and simply isnt the right approach to be followed.
Inlägg #38: Postat: 2002-11-18 16:11:00
David Woxberg
Återigen, Stefan: Det viktiga är inte att privatisera de grundläggande resurserna. Jag har redan gått igenom det, så det är ingen idé att upprepa samma sak om igen. Sedan vill jag inte tvinga världens fattiga till att liberalisera: jag menar bara att det är nödvändigt om man vill lämna fattigdom och misär.
Inlägg #39: Postat: 2002-11-18 16:25:00
David Woxberg
Frederik: I may have expressed myself a bit clumsy: of course liberalisation can be hard for developing countries. It may be hard to get it started, and in the process one can meet many hardships. But freedom, economic and political, is nevertheless a necessary precondition of wealth-creation.
Inlägg #40: Postat: 2002-11-18 19:29:00
Frederik
David: basically Id agree. But if you then again look at the economical imperialism thats often presented under neo-liberal clothing Im more often than not sceptical towards it. Furthermore, its by far not *the* solution for wealth-creation that it often itself claims to be. Many different approaches are needed in combination, some of which are even contrary to economical principles.
Showing page 2 of 3: 1  2  3
Laddar...