Alla ni som demonstrerar för Saddam

Showing page 2 of 2: 1  2
Inlägg #21: Postat: 2003-02-19 14:01:00
Mike
Im not blaming "the whole population" Im just saying that you cant just say that the warlords and their followers are something separate from Afghanistan in general. Its part of the make up of the country and something that the "whole population" has to deal with.
Inlägg #22: Postat: 2003-02-19 23:41:00
Frederik
Youre certainly right. But - to come back to how the discussion started - I still think that its an easy claim to make as someone living in safe and comfy Sweden. The whole population has also to deal with neighbouring countries with their own interests at stake, and without education or infrastructure and a scarce livelihood-basis at best its difficult to make a difference. Most of them are happy if they can survive, I guess.
Inlägg #23: Postat: 2003-02-19 23:44:00
Frederik
So if some say that the advantage of Taliban-times was that there wasnt any anarchy and warlordism around they probably have a point that we cant understand from our vantage point. Time will tell if Samuels claim that Afghanistan is better off now that the US has invaded it proves true. I hope so, but Im skeptical, and wouldnt necessarily blame the local population if things go wrong again.
Inlägg #24: Postat: 2003-02-20 13:58:00
Mike
You could look at it this way. The Taliban-repression only provided a temporary seize fire in the power struggle. As the repression is removed the conflict flares up again. compare w. ex Yugoslavia We would hope a peaceful solution can be found with the aid of the world community. I wouldnt blame anyone living in Afghanistan who prefers even a temporary seize fire to open conflict as they are concerned with their on survival.
Inlägg #25: Postat: 2003-02-20 14:11:00
Mike
However, being geographically and emotionally removed from the conflict does allow us to look at the bigger picture and to consider the best solution, not just for individual Afghanis living today, but also for the country as a whole in a longer perspective.
Inlägg #26: Postat: 2003-02-20 21:40:00
Mike
Oops, that should be "cease fire" obviously.
Inlägg #27: Postat: 2003-02-21 10:51:00
Frederik
You have a point. But Im still skeptical about the world-communitys goodwill, certainly now that the attention has shifted to Iraq. So - to come back to the initial discussion - it still remains to be seen whether the invasion will have helped Afghanistan on the long run, or whether it also took away the meagre cease-fire they had.
Inlägg #28: Postat: 2003-02-21 10:55:00
Frederik
Samuel argues quite simplistically that countries are better off after a successful US invasion. However, as several analysts have argued Iraq is a quagmire of ethnic strife, and Im also very skeptical towards the US attempts at nation building there. Certainly when, once the CNN-photogenic war is over, boring and expensive peacekeeping follows and attention turns again to the weak economy.
Inlägg #29: Postat: 2003-02-21 10:57:00
Frederik
Mind me, Im hoping the best I actually volunteered for ISAF - Im a reserve officer - but was unfortunately too late to get into the current contingent. But I certainly dont share Sirens simplistic optimism.
Showing page 2 of 2: 1  2
Laddar...