|
Inlägg #1: Postat: 2002-12-14 01:57:00
|
|
Frederik |
...and as Ill go to sleep now Ill ponder a bit on whether it has any application to the other koan that I never really understood: Whats the sound of one hand clapping?
|
| |
|
Inlägg #2: Postat: 2002-12-14 01:59:00
|
|
Frederik |
By the way, did you already read The Tree of Knowledge by Maturana and Varela? Mind me, I only read *about* it, but their theory of autopoiesis is to a certain extent a biologists equivalent to what youve written.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #3: Postat: 2002-12-14 13:47:00
|
|
Anders Lundberg |
Well, the tree makes no sound when no one is there because sound is our own "invention". But please note that I have said nothing about wether the falling of the tree has an enviromental impact.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #4: Postat: 2002-12-14 13:53:00
|
|
Anders Lundberg |
"The sound of one hand clapping" really means as I see it that there must be at least two counterparts of everything.
The concept of "difference" is the key to it all. I will soon write something about that.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #5: Postat: 2002-12-14 13:57:00
|
|
Anders Lundberg |
I have not read "The Tree of Knowledge" but I checked it up and it seems like there are some connections with my own ideas. Especially in the cybernetic angle.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #6: Postat: 2002-12-15 03:30:00
|
|
Frederik |
Answer to 4: I dont know whether I agree upon that one. The concept of difference is somehow also a human construction. The lines weve drawn between objects can be considered to be arbitrary and primarily based on our own needs.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #7: Postat: 2002-12-15 03:32:00
|
|
Frederik |
Answer to 5: Its the same idea, basically. M&V define knowledge as effective action in a domain of existence. In that sense we can never know whether something is true, only whether something works for us.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #8: Postat: 2002-12-15 14:16:00
|
|
Anders Lundberg |
Answer to 6: The differences based on our needs are instances of difference. Not concept. Nothingness well, not even that! is the alternative to difference. Maybe you could call nothingness "universal indifference".
|
| |
|
Inlägg #9: Postat: 2002-12-15 14:18:00
|
|
Anders Lundberg |
Answer to 7: I think I agree with that view.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #10: Postat: 2002-12-16 16:31:00
|
|
Frederik |
Answer to 8: I dont think so, actually. If you say separation instead of difference, then you get the opposite oneness. The opposite of nothingness would rather be being. Think of the concept Anders Lundberg: where do you draw the line? Youve been shaped by your environment and have shaped it as well, so who is to say that you are different from it? Theres also a certain degree of oneness there.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #11: Postat: 2002-12-16 16:35:00
|
|
Frederik |
Its only for practical reasons that we as humans as being different/separate from their environment. Another kinda silly example: my African friends always laugh at me when I once again have to admit that I cant differentiate between combed and uncombed curly African hair. For me it looks very much the same. For them however theres a huge difference. Its all in the eyes of the beholder.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #12: Postat: 2002-12-16 16:39:00
|
|
Frederik |
The mystical teachings of most major religions including Zen Buddhism emphasise the oneness of the universe, pointing out that it is our thinking processes ...or eating from the tree of knowledge that have created separation and difference as part of our own grammar to understand the world.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #13: Postat: 2002-12-16 16:40:00
|
|
Frederik |
Addenda to 11: the first sentence should be ...that we as humans see others as being...
|
| |