|
Inlägg #1: Postat: 2002-10-08 21:35:00
|
|
Eileen El Mogy |
Jaa, Greger. Med risk för att reta alla
tvivlare och förnekare -DET HAR JAG.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #2: Postat: 2002-10-08 23:37:00
|
|
Frederik |
Greger: whats proof for you? I personally just need a walk in a forest and watch the trees, birds, ants and mushrooms there to believe that theres more to the world than we as humans could ever hope to know. And my own academic training in botany, ecology and genetics has strengthened rather than weakened this belief.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #3: Postat: 2002-10-09 09:57:00
|
|
Greger |
Har du lust att ge en kort beskrivning på din upplevelse?
|
| |
|
Inlägg #4: Postat: 2002-10-09 10:09:00
|
|
Greger |
Frederik: Good for you but proof of a divine force to me would be an angel descending from the sky, a burning bush which talks to me, someone’s wounds closing up before my eyes after a physical trauma etc. BTW you are stating the obvious, of course there is more to the world than we realise. But uncertainty is not proof of a higher power.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #5: Postat: 2002-10-09 10:36:00
|
|
Frederik |
Greger: heres an example I usually use to demonstrate my point: you cant prove that your partner loves you. All the nice things she does she might also do out of very selfish reasons. All you can do is have faith in her love. When you do, the relationship flourishes. When you dont, it dies. Same for faith in God.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #6: Postat: 2002-10-09 11:41:00
|
|
enlighted evolution |
its nice playing with words but can
it really prove the excistence of gods?
seems to me that you think god has created everything you dont understand. you dont know how life was created and thereby you "create" a god to give you the aswer that you long for.
Believing in god gives you a reason for living and having a prof of gods excistens must be the greatest gift on earth. But believing in god just becouse you cant find the answers somewhere else is cowardice and week minded.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #7: Postat: 2002-10-09 13:37:00
|
|
Greger |
Frederik: Yes that your way of looking at it. But I need tangible evidence to believe in a specific higher being. Youve just chosen to believe in what I dont know based on your awe I presume for the world and its eco system.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #8: Postat: 2002-10-09 13:53:00
|
|
Frederik |
Im a plain Joe Christian, and yes, youre more or less right in what you say about me though Im also in awe about the phenomenon of human love, and lots of other things. Your own perspective on proof however - with all respect - makes me think of the saying For him who has only a hammer, everything looks like a nail. Religion is also about letting go of ones own claims on reality and learn to become aware of it as it really is.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #9: Postat: 2002-10-09 13:58:00
|
|
Frederik |
EnEv: You cant prove anything in religion, you can only have faith in it. And thats in essence a choice, nothing more and nothing less. Besides, religion is not about the *hows* of life science is much better there but about the *whys*.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #10: Postat: 2002-10-09 14:03:00
|
|
Frederik |
The issue of knowing and not knowing is important because through science we may get the feeling that we have control and will one day know everything, which is basically total philosophical bullshit. No matter how much we research, life will always be like a big question to us to which we have to give an answer through our lives.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #11: Postat: 2002-10-09 14:06:00
|
|
Frederik |
And then I dont consider it cowardice or weak-mindedness to consciously tackle the why dimension of life and learn from those who have tried to do it in the past. Its much easier to ignore it altogether through mindless entertainment and made-up-on-the-occasion rationalisations on why its right for me to behave the way I do.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #12: Postat: 2002-10-09 14:09:00
|
|
Frederik |
Mind me, living life consciously is not a monopoly of the religions, as for instance Sartre or Camus have proven. Nevertheless, I have so far not seen any secular tradition that systematically encourages people to live better and more conscious lives the way religion is doing. that its not always good at it is another discussion, though...
|
| |
|
Inlägg #13: Postat: 2002-10-09 14:09:00
|
|
Frederik |
Mind me, living life consciously is not a monopoly of the religions, as for instance Sartre or Camus have proven. Nevertheless, I have so far not seen any secular tradition that systematically encourages people to live better and more conscious lives the way religion is doing. that its not always good at it is another discussion, though...
|
| |
|
Inlägg #14: Postat: 2002-10-09 14:14:00
|
|
Greger |
I cant see any logical reasons to change my perspective that is why Ill probably remain an agnostic for the rest of my life.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #15: Postat: 2002-10-09 15:03:00
|
|
Frederik |
Logic is your hammer here. There are limits to what you can do and see with logic and reason alone. Though your agnostic point of view is fine with me.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #16: Postat: 2002-10-09 15:13:00
|
|
Martin |
Frederik: So you advocate being illogical and unreasonable. Well then, I believe arguments such as yours will lead to World War 3. I feel it in my heart. And Im strengthened in my belief by the time your message was sent, which was 15:05.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #17: Postat: 2002-10-09 16:45:00
|
|
Frederik |
Being aware of the limitations of logic and reason doesnt mean a wholesale condemnation of it, does it?
|
| |
|
Inlägg #18: Postat: 2002-10-09 17:58:00
|
|
Martin |
Who is condemning logic and reason? I just thought Id use another method for a while.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #19: Postat: 2002-10-09 18:56:00
|
|
Frederik |
Ok, but then you were swinging the pendulum all the way i.e. too far to the other side and not really making a good point at all, dont you think? Or did I miss something?
|
| |
|
Inlägg #20: Postat: 2002-10-09 20:05:00
|
|
Martin |
If you claim to gain knowledge by methods that dont have anything to do with logic or reason, how can we evaluate the validity of that "knowledge" if another person claims to have "illogical knowledge" that contradicts yours?
|
| |