Helt fel Ana. Lyckliga horor finns

Showing page 1 of 2: 1  2
Inlägg #1: Postat: 2002-09-21 16:33:00
Michael Lundahl
Mycket bra fråga Herman. Och nu till det som är riktigt viktigt: Vad är svaret?
Inlägg #2: Postat: 2002-09-21 17:31:00
Frederik
…and here’s where you make a mistake, Michael. Social statistics is one of those areas where you will never find objective answers. What’s a representative sample? How and what do you ask? How do you get in touch with prostitutes working in illegality, and can you expect that they will give accurate answers? …and so on and so on. Policy-making will always be fuzzy and coloured by values and opinions, and if you look for ‘objectivity’ there then you’re looking for an illusion.
Inlägg #3: Postat: 2002-09-21 17:57:00
Frederik
There have been several people in this and previous debates who came with firsthand experiences from prostitutes so-called ‘case histories’ in social science, which is scientifically valid data that you cannot discard just by saying that it’s ‘only one example’. I agree with what I think is your view that the Swedish legislation what I know of it, at least is kinda weird, and I’m myself a supporter of the Dutch approach with prostitutes having unions and paying taxes.
Inlägg #4: Postat: 2002-09-21 17:58:00
Frederik
Nevertheless, that’s only out of a ‘humanitarian’ pragmatic stance, to limit the exploitation that inevitably occurs in such a business even here in Holland to a minimum. I personally find prostitution morally highly questionable, and don’t consider it ‘just another service’ as you do. For every case history of a ‘happy whore’ you’ll find dozens of negative ones.
Inlägg #5: Postat: 2002-09-21 17:58:00
Frederik
You’ll never find accurate data about how many are ‘happy’ what’s that mean anyway? and how many aren’t, but the case histories alone should make you think twice what it is that you’re really arguing for. Is it: “Nobody knows exactly, so nobody should claim anything”? What comes to mind then is the man who carefully wanted to consider every step he made, and consequently spent his life on one leg.
Inlägg #6: Postat: 2002-09-21 18:02:00
Frederik
…or do you argue for a better legislation? In that case however I think you should pay much more weight to the negative stories that abound than you seem to do now. Even in Holland prostitution as a profession is not respected by the majority of society, and exploitation and ‘bad stories’ still abound. I’m sure that a system of laws that would reduce prostitution as a whole rather than limit its negative impact as it does now would be welcomed by most.
Inlägg #7: Postat: 2002-09-21 22:41:00
Christer H
Jag förstår heller inte alltid vad det är som ML vill uppnå. Men det är alltid nyttigt att ifrågasätta dogmer, och se saker ur andra vinklar. Jag och ML, tror jag anser att sex som tjänster och varor porr, felaktigt per automatik anses vara kvinnoförtryck och utnyttjande. Det ÄR så till stor del, men det BEHÖVER inte vara så. Är tex. bögporr kvinnoförtryck? Mvh CH
Inlägg #8: Postat: 2002-09-21 22:49:00
Christer H
Tänk tanken, att allt samhälleligt fördömande mot att sälja/köpa sexuella tjänster, skulle försvinna. Skulle det fortfarande vara så hemskt att runka av en handikappad man mot betalning? Skattat, med gummihandskar och under ordnade former. Eller att en exhibitionistisk lagd ung man smeker sig själv, inför en publik av gifta betalande kvinnor? Nä, varför skulle det vara det? Mvh CH
Inlägg #9: Postat: 2002-09-21 22:51:00
Christer H
Jag skulle mycket väl mot rätt betalning kunna tänka mig bådadera. Mvh CH
Inlägg #10: Postat: 2002-09-22 11:54:00
Frederik
Loose from the fact whether it’s male or female prostitution/pornography we’re talking about, it’s my personal opinion that the fact that sex is such a big issue anytime and everywhere is clearly a sign that it’s more than just another human need to be satisfied. It’s much more personal, touches the human ‘soul’ so to speak except for those who lost contact with theirs, and it’s always denigrating when something so personal is reduced to a mere commodity to be bought and sold.
Inlägg #11: Postat: 2002-09-22 11:54:00
Frederik
Many forms of erotic art are really beautiful and exciting! and do respect the personal integrity of their models. But what I’ve seen of pornography according to me reduces women to mere genitals and a pair of preferably big tits, while the value of men is only judged by the size of their dick. As for prostitution, I personally oppose it for the reason mentioned above…
Inlägg #12: Postat: 2002-09-22 11:55:00
Frederik
…and because it offers an opportunity for mainly husbands to cheat on their wives. If whores weren’t there they’d maybe think twice and either try to work on their relationship or end it, rather than choosing an easy way out that’s bound to leave people hurt on the long run a simplistic thought, I know, but you get my point. Anyway, it’s always a very ‘blurred’ area and it’s difficult to say where integrity is maintained and where exploitation begins.
Inlägg #13: Postat: 2002-09-22 12:06:00
Frederik
Quick addenda to my last argument: what I mentioned is only one example. In essence the argument comes down to - no matter whether in a relationship or not - sex as commodity makes it easy to avoid/ignore the personal dimension of sex, which is however necessary to maintain human integrity. Though I know that this statement alone is worth a debate on its own.
Inlägg #14: Postat: 2002-09-22 22:13:00
Michael Lundahl
Frederik: Bara för det är svårt att uppnå objektiva fakta så betyder det absolut INTE att vi för den sakens skull skall skita i det och köra vidare på svart-vita truismer och allmäna fördomar... därför attd et öeder otvivelaktigt till än större katastrof.
Inlägg #15: Postat: 2002-09-22 22:14:00
Michael Lundahl
Vad gäller sexualitet och vad det betyder för olika personer så finns det inget som säger "Så här skall det vara". Det finns några få "Så häör skall det INTE vara"... typ attd et inte skall vara ofrivilligt. Men vad sex är för olika personer och hur de hanterar det, det är inte för vare sig dig eller mig att lägga sig i.
Inlägg #16: Postat: 2002-09-22 23:21:00
Frederik
Answer to 14: No, absolutely not. But nevertheless, in this subject facts will always be subjective and context-related. Thats why you should ask yourself how nuanced your own thinking is as well. To me at least you dont create the impression of your views being balanced and objective, whatever objective means here.
Inlägg #17: Postat: 2002-09-22 23:27:00
Frederik
Answer to 15: Too easy a way out. Point is that its very difficult to judge when a certain behaviour for instance posing nude in popular magazines, or prostitution, for that matter has a negative influence on society and when it hasnt. And every do is also a dont, and vice-versa.
Inlägg #18: Postat: 2002-09-22 23:29:00
Frederik
The line for a policy-maker for instance between when to intervene and when to let things be is again very fuzzy and always open for debate, but that musnt prevent me from voicing my opinion if I think that a certain behaviour is damaging for society as a whole. Im part of society, and should therefore both be conscious of and take responsibility for my role in co-shaping it.
Inlägg #19: Postat: 2002-09-23 09:56:00
Michael Lundahl
Visst är det öppet för detbatt... eller snarare: Debatten måste öppnas.... och det är det jag med mitt lilla strå här försöker göra... därför att idag är debatten väldigt enahanda, sluten och enkelriktad.
Inlägg #20: Postat: 2002-09-23 11:17:00
Frederik
Ok, you have a point here. But dont you think that youre as dogmatic in your liberalism as you accuse others of being in their stance against the sex-industry?
Showing page 1 of 2: 1  2
Laddar...