"Hora" som kränkning, del II

Inlägg #1: Postat: 2002-09-17 18:12:00
Frederik
…including norms of sexuality, women’s physical integrity etc. If you want to achieve respect for prostitution as a profession, then it’s those norms you have to tackle/debate. Your argument that the pejorative meaning of the word ‘whore’ is an expression of the patriarchal oppression of women doesn’t hold either…
Inlägg #2: Postat: 2002-09-17 18:12:00
Frederik
The ‘institution prostitution’ is in itself an expression of patriarchal oppression, and the use of ‘whore’ as an insult just illustrates this fact think of the insult ‘nigger’ which originated when blacks were used as slaves. Last but not least, remember that it’s perfectly possible to respect whores as human beings while strongly opposing the work they do because of its oppressive nature. My feelings about the word ‘whore’ say nothing about my attitude towards whores as individuals.
Inlägg #3: Postat: 2002-09-17 18:13:00
Frederik
Anyway, I think Susanne ES was right with her final comment: can’t we change the topic? There are lots of issues that are more interesting than this one. Right now all you’ve achieved is making a fool of yourself.
Inlägg #4: Postat: 2002-09-18 08:20:00
Michael Lundahl
Non-issue? Det går människor på gatan och DÖR bara för att samhället säger att det är helt ok att inte respektera dem! Vissa blir inhandlade som slavar från andra länder och tvingade till total förnedring... och du säger att det är ett non-issue och att vi ska byta ämne för nu vill du inte prata mer om det?! Fy faaaan säger jag bara!
Inlägg #5: Postat: 2002-09-18 10:49:00
Frederik
Read... but not understood. Re-read my comments carefully, and youll notice that what I say is that the discussion of the use of the word whore is a total non-issue, doesnt add to the debate, and certainly doesnt help the whores themselves. I quote myself: "If you want to achieve respect for prostitution as a profession, then it’s those norms you have to tackle/debate."
Inlägg #6: Postat: 2002-09-18 13:44:00
Christer H
Jag blir mållös Frederik. "it’s those norms you have to tackle/debate", det är ju just DET som Michael försöker göra! Tyvärr så missförstår alla? inklusive du, det. Mvh CH
Inlägg #7: Postat: 2002-09-18 14:38:00
Frederik
CH: All ML does is ask *why* whore is an insult, then claim that its because of the low respect society has for prostitutes, and then - I assume - claim that we should stop using the word in this sense because we are contributing to the oppression of women by doing so. How silly can things get, really?
Inlägg #8: Postat: 2002-09-18 14:39:00
Frederik
First, he just discusses the misuse of a word, as if the word in itself were a problem. It’s not politically correct in the US nowadays to use the insult ‘nigger’. Did that change anything about the discrimination against blacks? Hardly. The word is only the manifestation of an attitude which has thousands of ways of expressing itself.
Inlägg #9: Postat: 2002-09-18 14:39:00
Frederik
Second, I’m convinced that the use of ‘whore’ as an insult is probably the last thing the prostitutes themselves worry about. If ML really wants to debate the oppression of women, he should be discussing topics such as the trade of women for the sex-industry or legal rights for prostitutes. His insisting on debating the interpretation of ‘whore’ feels rather pathetic to me, like debating whether the colour of the flames should be described as red or orange when in fact the house is on fire.
Inlägg #10: Postat: 2002-09-18 17:20:00
Christer H
Michael ifrågasätter, försöker få oss alla att tänka till. vad vårt eget språkbruk kan säga oss om egna fördomar och förutfattade meningar. Detta är ALLTID viktigt att göra. Språket ÄR viktigt. Tyvärr så har denna "debatt" fastnat på en "könskrigssandlådenivå", som inte leder någon vart, dina inlägg inräknade, Frederik. Mvh CH
Inlägg #11: Postat: 2002-09-18 18:20:00
Frederik
You’re free to have your opinion. However, I still see nothing original or even relevant in what ML has said here. Fine with me if he wants to discuss our attitudes towards prostitution. But not like this. His argument here goes like “ ‘whore’ has a negative connotation; whores are women; so if you use the word ‘whore’ as an insult then you are contributing to the oppression of women”. Simplistic, don’t you think?
Inlägg #12: Postat: 2002-09-18 18:20:00
Frederik
What if prostitution itself is an oppression of women and therefore has a negative connotation? ML doesn’t consider the difference between the value of an individual and of the job that s/he does, didn’t react to arguments in that direction, and basically says that to respect women I have to respect prostitution. Not surprising that feminists get upset about such a ridiculous claim call that one ‘konssandladeniva’ if you want, but I can’t think of a better word to describe his arguments.
Inlägg #13: Postat: 2002-09-18 18:23:00
Frederik
Priftis, please warn me if you get the impression that Im behaving like a tvarsaker debattor again... :
Inlägg #14: Postat: 2002-09-18 19:46:00
Christer H
Man har allmänt debatterat det alltmer frekventa bruket av ordet "hora". Speciellt bland pojkar och unga män. Här handlar det inte om prostitution utan om flickor som påstås ha/har ett friare sexliv än "normen" föreskriver. Denna dubbla betydelse av ordet har också ML behandlat. Prostitution i sig är fö. helt ok, om det sker av fri vilja. Mvh CH
Inlägg #15: Postat: 2002-09-18 20:24:00
Frederik
Ok, it could be that I lived in a context where the word whore has hardly ever been used, which may make it seem less relevant to me than to, say, a parent who hears his/her kid use it all the time. But even then you could ask yourself in how far ML has really addressed the essence of the problem; I still think that his arguments are flawed.
Laddar...