|
Inlägg #1: Postat: 2002-11-20 10:22:00
|
|
Frederik |
Incidentally, she enjoyed partying and fun just as much as we did I met her during student congresses. Only that she didnt drink any alcohol, didnt go for superficial romantic affairs and... well, wore her veil at all times. She was very free, but in her own way.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #2: Postat: 2002-11-20 11:13:00
|
|
Fredrik Jung Abbou |
I know ´girls like this to Frederik. Here i London. But do you think your female friend gives a different answer to the question if the veil is a relic from something not so cute from a girls perspective?
|
| |
|
Inlägg #3: Postat: 2002-11-20 11:24:00
|
|
Frederik |
Ive lost contact with her, so I dont know what she herself would say. From the discussions I had with her on veils and on Islam however I recall that she didnt perceive it as an oppressive relic. I guess she found the Western emphasis on good looks way more stifling from a girls perspective than her veil was to her actually thats one of the reasons why she wore it.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #4: Postat: 2002-11-20 13:45:00
|
|
Fredrik Jung Abbou |
Disregarding of what she thinks. What do you think? You, who have impressed us with your sense of analysis and scope. You see no relation whatsoever between the islamic veil forced on some girls as a way of opression? You speak of ONE person that liked to wear it, I know many that likes to wear it, and some who dont but dont dare to disobey.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #5: Postat: 2002-11-20 13:46:00
|
|
Fredrik Jung Abbou |
What about the people that dont and is not given a choice? I think you want to be politically correct Frederik because I have not seen you taking a narrow view like this before.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #6: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:17:00
|
|
Frederik |
: You have a point: I dont like to offend people, though its not a matter of being PC. I have my own thoughts and ideas, many of which I believe wouldnt fit in the mainstream.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #7: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:20:00
|
|
Frederik |
Concerning the veil issue: my own view is that no-one is in a position to enforce his/her views or way of being on someone else if that someone else isnt hurting anyone. Im against Islam forcefully imposing for instance a dressing code on its practicioners same Christianity, for that matter. Like this Calvinist in Baarneveld close to where I live who refused to sell something to a woman because she was wearing trousers.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #8: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:21:00
|
|
Frederik |
Its a difficult issue, however, because enforcing can take many forms, and todays fashion industry is pretty good at it as well, if youd ask me. I guess its just human to want everyone to adhere to certain predictable labels and roles.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #9: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:24:00
|
|
Frederik |
Ramonas views however are way too radical for my taste. Having known Airin the friend in question I know that for her its not a matter of oppressing anyone, but of affirming her identity as a Muslim. You could say that the Muslim equivalent to Ramona could be someone who is against people wearing a little cross around their neck because of all the evils Christians have done during the Crusades. A bit far-fetched, but you get my point.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #10: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:30:00
|
|
Frederik |
Ironically, with her views Ramona is in fact oppressing people like Airin to express their identity the way they want it, only because they freely choose to wear what for her seems like a symbol of oppression, but for them simply isnt. And thats why - obviously - I dont agree.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #11: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:33:00
|
|
Frederik |
By the way, the whole discussion as I see it turns around the issue of hurting someone. Ramona may say that by wearing the veil Airin & Co. are indirectly justifying a practice that is used to oppress women elsewhere. I would however say that this influence is marginal, and largely offset by their right of expressing themselves. Its difficult however to produce facts on this issue, and in the end itll all come down to value-judgements.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #12: Postat: 2002-11-20 18:39:00
|
|
Frederik |
...as for people wearing veils on TV: I really wouldnt mind. I wouldnt complain either if a Rastafarian would wear his rastas while directing his programme, for that matter. As long as they do their job and dont misuse their function to actively promote their beliefs I really see no reason why they shouldnt be allowed to be themselves.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #13: Postat: 2002-11-21 01:55:00
|
|
Fredrik Jung Abbou |
Of course Ramons way of putting things shade her possibilities of gaining any understanding and sort of transforming people to say the opposite. To cut her som slack, she would absolutely be an opressor if converted, but what would she become to the thousand of girls that feel opressed Frederik? Opressor and saviour then I guess-;
|
| |
|
Inlägg #14: Postat: 2002-11-21 01:59:00
|
|
Fredrik Jung Abbou |
I still believe that u and others mix things up when comparing religious opression from Islam, Judaism or other and western fashion slavery. This stems not from opression but from a complete meltdown in respect forthe individual to create massmarkets and the individuals total capitulation in breaking these chains strong words here maybe The opressor here is within ourselves who put up with it. A situation not comparable with that of a person opressed in the way we talk of now.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #15: Postat: 2002-11-21 02:05:00
|
|
Frederik |
You may have a point, but Ill have to think it through first. I actually believe that even with religious oppression its the oppressor within ourselves that is at work. That one who wants a predictable and seemingly safe world without surprises that might challenge his/her views. Religion and fashion are only two channels it has found to express him/herself.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #16: Postat: 2002-11-21 02:08:00
|
|
Frederik |
I dont know whether its directly related Im just back from a pubcrawl and my thinking isnt that straight. Belgian beers the best!!! Westmalle at folket!, but I can recommend Pedagogy of the Oppressed by Paulo Freire. Extremely tough read francophone intellectual lingo, if you see what I mean, but at the time I read it it offered me fascinating insights into the mechanisms of oppression.
|
| |
|
Inlägg #17: Postat: 2002-11-21 02:09:00
|
|
Frederik |
Mind me, I only got halfway before I gave up. But still...
|
| |